Did Apple kill design? and implication for HR solutions

I was recently reading a piece by two former Apple designers on how Apple is giving design a bad name by focusing more on the “beauty” rather than on the efficiency: Apple is destroying design. Worse, it is revitalizing the old belief that design is only about making things look pretty. This relates completely to my personal experience with iPhone: how many how of you knows that you can “undo” by shaking your phone?


More seriously, it made me reflect on HR solutions and selection process. I am involved in over 40 vendor selection process per year. And most of them now include a “Proof of Concept” day with users. I am a strong believer that it is a must have in any selection process. But most of the time it ends up in a beauty contest because there is not enough time to drill into details of the end to end process or not enough anticipation on the content. Remember not all that glitters is gold!

My favorite quote in the article is: Design combines an understanding of people, technology, society, and business. The production of beautiful objects is only one small component of modern design. So true! At SAP, Product Managers like to remind that they are designing what people need and not what they want, same as did Henry Ford.

henry ford

So, where am I heading? Well, you – HR practitioners – have the task to select the best solution for the years to come. Your timing is pretty short. And beauty should not over shadow the efficiency and outcomes. Below is a summary of everything that the design of the solution shoud cover:


So, here are some ideas to bring back the global view:

  • Ask the vendor: what is your design philosophy? ie beyond the user interface. What do you want to achieve?
  • Make sure you have “killer scenario” rather than a beauty contest: what are your current pain(s)?
  • Think « outside » HR too: your solution will be the backbone for many others
  • Multi-device access is a must: but the use cases need to be beyond the hype and be realistic to your policies and maturity as well

Here are a few examples picked up from recent RFPs that capture the essence of good design on HR:

  • Modern solution needs to be extensible: one of the goals for a global HCM solution should be to reduce the shadow IT components (i.e. any Excel or SharePoint based applications you built for HR needs). True extensibility should let you configure new parts in the solution. One global customer had a request: being able to track a volunteer log. Because it is important for them and they have a strong focus on giving back. And so we show them how to do it easily and with simple configuration. By leveraging true extensibility, you are upgrade proof, consistant in security and no integration!


  • A typical recruitment process has many interactions happening with third party solutions. For example, a candidate is likely to use a social network profile to apply. But which one? Depending on the geography, it is will not be the same. In France, it will be Viadeo. But in Germany and Eastern Europe, it will be Xing. Can your vendor be your global business partner?
  • applyEmployee and manager self-services are a key element of any HR transformation business case. How do you make sure ESS and MSS will deliver on their promises and not break the process? Take this example: when adding a dependent to an employee record, you need to be able to add an attachment, but also in many countries to declare a fiscal status. If this cannot be achieved in one step and if you need to do that in different local system, well, your process is broken. The data will need to be completed by a different operator and cause frustration. This will drive down user adoption but more importantly your efficiency will decrease dramatically.


Does this make sense? What are your experience(s) with vendor selection process? And more importantly after go live? Where the promises of the nice UI meeting your expectations of end to end process?

Related post

How Apple is giving design a bad name inspiration for this article

The value of localization for HR and HR Systems by me

It’s Official: Intelligent Services Is Paving the Way for Business Transformation by David Ragones

What is your speed of change? by Patrick Willer


2 réflexions au sujet de « Did Apple kill design? and implication for HR solutions »

Laisser un commentaire

Entrez vos coordonnées ci-dessous ou cliquez sur une icône pour vous connecter:

Logo WordPress.com

Vous commentez à l'aide de votre compte WordPress.com. Déconnexion /  Changer )

Photo Google+

Vous commentez à l'aide de votre compte Google+. Déconnexion /  Changer )

Image Twitter

Vous commentez à l'aide de votre compte Twitter. Déconnexion /  Changer )

Photo Facebook

Vous commentez à l'aide de votre compte Facebook. Déconnexion /  Changer )

Connexion à %s